Bam Bam
Established Member
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2024
- Messages
- 773
- Reaction score
- 661
- Points
- 234
- Location
- Oxfordshire, UK
- Driving
- MG4 SE SR
Exactly right.Mathematically, it's still just a £300 bet on whether your car gets written off and, if it does, you get a nice lump sum. The insurers will have priced the GAP insurance premium according to their risk of a write-off, whilst still earning themselves a healthy profit. It's just gambling with a veneer.
If your friend didn't have GAP insurance, his insurance would pay market value (e.g. £25K) and then he buys another similar vehicle for £25K. No loss, no gain. If he feels that £25K is undervalued he can negotiate with the insurer to get a 'fair' price.
If his complaint is that his nice new car lost £25K in 24 months, then that's a different issue and his expected loss from buying a new 5 series for £45K in the first place.
You already have insurance. Gap insurance is a hedging bet on the side. If it was £1 it would be worth it, but if it is hundreds of pounds to hedge against something that is extremely unlikely then it doesn't seem worth it to me.
Insurance companies aren't charities and there is a reason they get dealers on commission do a hard sell on gap insurance.