M44LCY
Established Member
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2024
- Messages
- 105
- Reaction score
- 132
- Points
- 38
- Age
- 69
- Location
- Fife, Scotland
- Driving
- MG5 Trophy LR
With respect, I didn't say that having 2 RCBOs is dangerous. "If you have 2 RCBOs rated at the same value it will be pot luck which one (or both) will break first in the event of a fault." You're using "pot luck" to describe the scenario that I described as a potential conflict. Neither of these is strictly correct but both convey the sentiment that having 2 RCDs or RCBOs is not good practice.That's not strictly true - it's obviously OK to use a 5A rated extension cable to supply a device rated at 1kW or less. Fuses are rated to protect the cable (and no other reason) in a fault condition. The rating for a ring main circuit is 32A (but the socket is obviously only rated at 13A. A '10A rated' cable should not have a 13A fuse in it but, as the standard fuses are 1A, 3A, 5A and 13A, the fuse will not fulfil its purpose of protecting the cable. In my opinion 10A rated (1mm2) extension cables should not be allowed to be sold.
There is also an earlier post which talks about not having 2 RCDs (RCBOs) stating that they will cause a 'conflict'. This is untrue. If you have 2 RCBOs rated at the same value it will be pot luck which one (or both) will break first in the event of a fault. It can be argued that it would be good practice to have a lower rated RCBO for devices outside as the user is likely to be in a more vulnerable position (could be standing on wet grass for instance). A separate RCBO would also prevent 'nuisance' tripping of the whole house because of an issue outside. The point is having 2 RCBOs doesn't make it dangerous.
"A separate RCBO would also prevent 'nuisance' tripping of the whole house because of an issue outside." Surely the whole point in having RCBOs in the consumer unit is that when a fault condition occurs, only the affected circuit will shut down rather than a bank of circuits or the whole house. I'm not sure why you would want more than one protecting a single device?
Anyway, this is way beyond what was needed to answer the original question so I'll leave it at that.