The EV is FULL

@Hadrian, your car probably has the charging fault and I hope it gets fixed quickly.

However some simple tests could have localised the fault and, perhaps, resolved it earlier or given damning evidence to the garage. (For example see the case at the end of the thread 'MG4 Spotted'). As other posters have said testing the links in the charging chain would have been useful, particularly as, I suspect, the garage does not operate with Octopus Intelligent Go and may not have your EVSE and cable

We EV Owners are, in some ways, pioneers and I am certain that members of this Forum could educate the dealers a lot. Some dealers might resent this but others will welcome the fact that initial fault-finding had been carried out. And the fact that pointing out that early Trophys suffer CCU failures (search the Forum) might have helped them avoid nugatory tests and software changes.

I note you say that the app declares the EV to be 'Full'. As far as I know the MG4 does tell the EVSE its state of charge, so this must be an estimation by the EVSE/App which could be wrong. (As far as I know, MG has not released its charging API.)
You're right. The Master tech at my dealership is on this forum although I believe he just lurks . He's advised me that he's gathered more information from members here than from MG
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi, I have a Trophy LR 2023 too and a Zappi2 charger. I also moved recently to Intelligent Octopus Go from a simpler Octopus tariff.
Since this change I have had exactly the same issue you described, ie: Octopus sets up the charging schedule, l wait patiently until the following morning when l find that only about 0.5kWh of charge was added to the car, after which the 'EV is full' message.

I therefore have to revert to manually setting the Zappi to Fast charge the car, which is a pain if you want to capitalise on the Octopus cheap rate periods.

Have you found a solution to this problem?
Just a thought, I'm finding the latest Octopus app sets the default time to be ready at sometime the following evening. Check that you set the ready by time to before you need it. Solved my problem.
 
Hi, I have a Trophy LR 2023 too and a Zappi2 charger. I also moved recently to Intelligent Octopus Go from a simpler Octopus tariff.
Since this change I have had exactly the same issue you described, ie: Octopus sets up the charging schedule, l wait patiently until the following morning when l find that only about 0.5kWh of charge was added to the car, after which the 'EV is full' message.

I therefore have to revert to manually setting the Zappi to Fast charge the car, which is a pain if you want to capitalise on the Octopus cheap rate periods.

Have you found a solution to this problem?
UPDATE.
The failure to charge problem appears to have been solved.

The MG 4 was delivered to Frasers of Falkirk on 9 December 2024 and during the remainder of the month, no fault finding feedback was provided to me.

On Monday 6 January 2025 at 11am I visited Frasers of Falkirk and walked into their workshop and asked to speak to the technician who was dealing with my car.
Unknown to me, I was speaking with the Service Manager who declined my request and immediately tried to usher me to the Service Reception.
I was aware that the service reception personnel knew nothing about the technical details of the fault diagnosis.
Fortunately, I quickly realised that the service manager who was indignant and evasive knew what tests had been carried out and I told him that I believed that I had located the fault by using a UK data base.

I explained that the early MG 4 Trophy without the rear windscreen wiper, had a known fault with the CCU which was preventing charging.
The service manager was obviously taken aback and admitted that this was a conclusion which the garage had made and they were waiting approval from MG Technical.

At 2:55pm on the same day, less than 3 hours after my visit to Frasers of Falkirk, I received a phone call from Service Reception to say that MG Technical had approved the replacement of the CCU, the part was located within the UK and would be delivered within 2 days.

On Thursday 9 January 2025, in the morning, I was able to collect the MG 4, having had the CCU replaced and was fully charged.

I had intended to delay this update to ensure that the replacement CCU can cope with the menu of stop/start charging offered by Octopus Go.
Unfortunately, I have only used the car for short journeys and there has been no need to charge.

My advice to anyone with a similar charging problem, is to tell the MG Agent, that this is a known problem and to check out the CCU.

Should there be any other charging problems, I will update this post.

I am very grateful to those of our members who have contributed to this fault finding issue.

It's a pity the MG Dealers don't us "common sense" in asking around!

UPDATE.
The failure to charge problem appears to have been solved.

The MG 4 was delivered to Frasers of Falkirk on 9 December 2024 and during the remainder of the month, no fault finding feedback was provided to me.

On Monday 6 January 2025 at 11am I visited Frasers of Falkirk and walked into their workshop and asked to speak to the technician who was dealing with my car.
Unknown to me, I was speaking with the Service Manager who declined my request and immediately tried to usher me to the Service Reception.
I was aware that the service reception personnel knew nothing about the technical details of the fault diagnosis.
Fortunately, I quickly realised that the service manager who was indignant and evasive knew what tests had been carried out and I told him that I believed that I had located the fault by using a UK data base.

I explained that the early MG 4 Trophy without the rear windscreen wiper, had a known fault with the CCU which was preventing charging.
The service manager was obviously taken aback and admitted that this was a conclusion which the garage had made and they were waiting approval from MG Technical.

At 2:55pm on the same day, less than 3 hours after my visit to Frasers of Falkirk, I received a phone call from Service Reception to say that MG Technical had approved the replacement of the CCU, the part was located within the UK and would be delivered within 2 days.

On Thursday 9 January 2025, in the morning, I was able to collect the MG 4, having had the CCU replaced and was fully charged.

I had intended to delay this update to ensure that the replacement CCU can cope with the menu of stop/start charging offered by Octopus Go.
Unfortunately, I have only used the car for short journeys and there has been no need to charge.

My advice to anyone with a similar charging problem, is to tell the MG Agent, that this is a known problem and to check out the CCU.

Should there be any other charging problems, I will update this post.

I am very grateful to those of our members who have contributed to this fault finding issue.

It's a pity the MG Dealers don't us "common sense" in asking around!
I have just noticed a post by Arog1354 concerning the charge schedules set by the MG app.
If you are using Octopus Intelligent Go, the charging schedules will be set automatically when you plug the car into your charger.
You MUST ensure that all other schedules, i.e. the car, the charger etc are deactivated although you should set the battery charge level within the iSmart app. I my case I set this at 80%.
If you set charging schedules in any app, it will be in conflict with Octopus Intelligent Go.
 
Once the SoC has come down to, say 70% or lower, do a test charge with the slider set to 80%. (Don't bother with a schedule - just do a charge). If the charge stops at 80% then all good; if not then you'll need software updates.
 
The MG4 was collected on 9 January 2025, having had the CCU replaced and after two home charging sessions it has dutifully charged to 80% without further issues.
I have also ascertained from Frasers of Falkirk theat the only intervention which they made to the car was the replacement of the CCU and there were no software upgrades.
 

Are you enjoying your MG4?

  • Yes

    Votes: 908 77.7%
  • I'm in the middle

    Votes: 171 14.6%
  • No

    Votes: 90 7.7%
Support us by becoming a Premium Member

Latest MG EVs video

MG Hybrid+ EVs OVER-REVVING & more owner feedback
Subscribe to our YouTube channel
Back
Top Bottom