My driving is mainly 5 mile commute and the odd shopping trip so nothing over 40mph really, so will it be enough to charge the battery to give me good mpg?
Tia. Nick.
Hi Nick,
As you know, any car will be less efficient in winter, regardless of whether it is petrol, diesel, EV , PHEV or HEV. Once the HEV is up to operating temperature, which should not take long, the MG3 should switch over to EV mode. Comparison tests by reviewers against the likes of the Suzuki Swift have indicated the Swift as being more efficient in the manual version and marginally so in the CVT version. Remember that the Swift is considerably lighter but it has less interior room. Being a Suzuki, there should be no question about reliability. It has however scored low on NCAP testing. The qualifier here is that the MG3 Hybrid has yet to be tested.
Other questions that you ask yourself are:
- Do you want a car with an automatic transmission, or would you be happy with a manual? If your commute is in stop/start traffic, the automatic option might be more relaxing. I wanted an automatic for that very reason.
- Based on the low mileage you mention, were there any issues running a diesel, as that can be a magnet for DPF issues for some?
The Dacia Sandero is reasonably economical in manual form, I'm not sure about the automatic version.
The Yaris Hybrid is quoted as being more economical, but there is a considerable price difference, so it would all come down to your price to change and what your budget is.
I would suggest making a shortlist and test-driving all of them. See can you get an extended test drive, my MG dealer let me take it out unaccompanied with the instructions to "take it for a long drive, no need to hurry back". I even went back for a second test a week or two later, once I had done my sums.
I had been driving diesel for 15 years and find the fuel economy at the moment to be not far off what I was getting in those. The reason that I didn't go for diesel this time around, is that my mileage has decreased considerably over the last few years, and thinking ahead of when I plan to change it, what will the resale be on a diesel in 5 years?