MG4 Reduction Gearbox Oil Leak

[AndyL61]

I'll take that as a no then.?

 

[bowfer]

Leaked (sic) photos of redesigned gearbox with fast level reading for dealers

 

[AndyL61]

Leaked (sic) photos of redesigned gearbox with fast level reading for dealers

View attachment 16594

There's nothing in it ! ?

 

[Eber]

There's nothing in it ! ?

There's your solution. ?

 

[bowfer]

There's nothing in it ! ?

It’s special MG fluid that matches the colour of the sight gauge

 

[Cocijo]

they signed of the paperwork as all ok no oil leak road tested.i not noticed it until start weekend due to driveway patched I have took photos of under tray there’s lots more oil leaked last time was only very small amounts

you should send that last pic to MG customer service. Says it all.

they signed of the paperwork as all ok no oil leak road tested.i not noticed it until start weekend due to driveway patched I have took photos of under tray there’s lots more oil leaked last time was only very small amounts

 

[Mars6394]

you should send that last pic to MG customer service. Says it all.

Sent all photos over to finance company just waiting to hear back.when I got in it this morning I also got the key not recognised fault again it just gets worse and worse this car then this afternoon get a call regarding another recall lol

 

[stevegus]

I will probably at some point change my oil as I don't believe it should last a lifetime. Probably looking at around 20k which for me will be around 16 months of ownership. Hopefully it will still be in good condition and at a reasonable level. Do you think MG will be doing a check on condition and possibly level at 1st service due to the leak issue ?

I dont think any car in the history of ever gets gearbox or axle oil checked / changed at 20k

 

[Cocijo]

I does sound silly but it is just possible that MG do add a gearbox check to the service to protect themselves from future failures/claims.

 

[Deleted member 10041]

I dont think any car in the history of ever gets gearbox or axle oil checked / changed at 20k

When you read macadoodles post about the state of the oil he drained out of his it doesn't bode well for what that would actually look like at 20000 miles

 

[AndyL61]

I dont think any car in the history of ever gets gearbox or axle oil checked / changed at 20k

I'm thinking of that because it's beyond the first service but not a milage that should cause any problems to a gearbox. If it looks ok then I can confidently leave it longer.

 

[Macadoodle]

When you read macadoodles post about the state of the oil he drained out of his it doesn't bode well for what that would actually look like at 20000 miles

Yep, the car was a substantial cash outlay for me, and I certainly feel a lot better now I don't have a crap load of metallic particles suspended in the gear oil.
I'm sure it was totally normal break in 'silt' as it was incredibly fine but I'm also sure fresh oil would be a better lubricant for the future.
Spoiling the ship for a ha'p'orth o tar springs to mind

 

[tsedge]

These kinds of gearboxes are not new technology and the MG4 is hardly a high-stress application, plus MG have used similar on the MG5 which has no problems I have seen, so I think the gearboxes are going to be just fine. It is easy to imagine problems but better to wait for evidence of a problem first, or risk spending time and energy on the imaginary.

 

[Deleted member 10041]

These kinds of gearboxes are not new technology and the MG4 is hardly a high-stress application, plus MG have used similar on the MG5 which has no problems I have seen, so I think the gearboxes are going to be just fine. It is easy to imagine problems but better to wait for evidence of a problem first, or risk spending time and energy on the imaginary.

It's the question over the oil level that is the big unknown in this case though, the MG 5 doesn't leak oil everywhere

 

[tsedge]

It's the question over the oil level that is the big unknown in this case though, the MG 5 doesn't leak oil everywhere

As I said, evidence first, or we get lost in speculation on speculation. Where are all the gearbox failures? If they start happening, we will know there's a problem, although it will all be covered by warranty anyway.

 

[Deleted member 10041]

As I said, evidence first, or we get lost in speculation on speculation. Where are all the gearbox failures? If they start happening, we will know there's a problem, although it will all be covered by warranty anyway.

Agree completely but it is the great unknown, the long term impact if the box is being run with less, it could be fine, it could impact it in other ways, stopping short of failure. Nobody knows.

I think the only thing that could be said is if it's true the levels have been dropped that MG are taking a gamble.

 

[Les burrows]

It's the question over the oil level that is the big unknown in this case though, the MG 5 doesn't leak oil everywhere

Ok well I might have posted this before I know I have looked at it.
The oil type and capacity is the same on all the vehicles in question.
Oil type on all models is
Shell E-Fluids E6 iX (SL2808)
Capacity
MG4. 0.9 litres.
MG5, MK1, 0.9 litres
MG5, MK 2, 0.9 litres
So might well appear it’s the same unit in use across the brand on there EVs
Les

 

[Deleted member 10041]

What is different about the MG 4 that causes it to leak???

 

[Ian Key]

Has anyone got a photo of the MG5 breather?

 

[Les burrows]

Has anyone got a photo of the MG5 breather?

Probably not because the MG5 either of them has never given an issue as far as I’m aware but if someone is driving a MG5 with the motor cover removed I’m sure it will be quite easy to get one.
Les